Can’t find the exact yarn your pattern calls for? Learn how to confidently substitute yarn with this helpful guide from The Bear & Fox Yarn Den.

Have you ever fallen head-over-heels for a pattern… only to discover the yarn it calls for is discontinued, impossible to find, or not quite your style? Don’t worry, this happens all the time, and we’re here to help.

At The Bear & Fox Yarn Den, we see it nearly every week: a customer walks in clutching a well-loved pattern (or a screenshot from 2011), looking puzzled because that yarn? It no longer exists.

But good news: you can absolutely substitute another yarn—and often end up with something even better. Here’s how to do it without unraveling your sanity:

1. Start with the Yarn Weight

First things first—check the weight of the original yarn. Is it a fingering weight? Worsted? Chunky? That’s your starting line.

Pro Tip: If you’re unsure, look up the yarn on Ravelry or YarnSub.com to see how it’s classified.

2. Match the Gauge

Even within the same weight category, yarns can behave very differently. Knit or crochet a gauge swatch with your substitute yarn. This helps ensure your project will turn out the right size, and not accidentally fit your hamster instead of your best friend. Unless your best friend is your hamster in that case... you do you, boo.

Yes, we know swatching feels like the vegetables of yarn work. But trust us, it’s worth it. 

3. Compare Fiber Content

The fiber content affects everything—from stretch and drape to stitch definition and warmth.

• Wool is bouncy and forgiving.

• Cotton has less stretch and more weight.

• Alpaca adds warmth and a soft halo.

• Acrylic is low-maintenance and budget-friendly.

Choose a substitute with a similar feel, or embrace the differences for a unique twist.

4. Check the Yardage

Your new yarn might come in different yardage per skein. Make sure to calculate how many skeins you’ll need based on total yards or meter, not just the number of balls.

We’re happy to do the math for you at the shop, just ask!

5. Color Matters (But It’s Also the Fun Part)

When the original colorway is unavailable, don’t stress—this is your chance to make the project yours. Whether you’re a neutrals enthusiast or craving bold jewel tones, your yarn choice tells your story.

Bonus: Use Our Expertise

Bring your pattern into The Bear & Fox Yarn Den—we love a good substitution challenge! We’ll help you find just the right yarn, maybe even from our own exclusive Bear & Fox line (hello, Swanky and Sparkle Pants ????).

Final Thoughts

Yarn substitution is part art, part science, and always a little adventure. So next time your dream pattern includes an elusive or extinct yarn, don’t let that stop you.

You’ve got this—and we’ve got you.

Want help with your next project?

Visit us in store or browse online—our team is always ready to help match patterns with yarns that actually exist.

Happy stitching,

Drew & Justin

The Bear & Fox Yarn Den

<< PREVIOUS POST   NEXT POST >>